Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Bullfighting

Suzy:

I came across this post from the last time we were in Spain and I thought that it should belong on this site instead. Just for the record, I haven't been back to a bullfight. So here you go:

Monday, June 21, 2004

Submitted by Suzy

So, the bullfight. Let´s talk about that. For being a person with certain convictions about animals (who doesn´t eat red meat for example), I can honestly say that the bullfight two weekends ago was... amazing. I won´t say that I´m a fan, nor that I´m against it, simply that it...affected me. Deeply. Especially the last fight. There were six bulls in all that day, with three Toreros (Matadors), each Torero killing two bulls: one two three and one two three (in order). I think that it affected quite a few of us, but my experience especially was one of deep respect, admiration, and appreciation of the rhythms and profound culture of the event. During the whole time, I was a bit squeemish and unsure whether to walk out or stay seated. They killed all five, first driving barbs into the extremely tough flesh at the back of the neck to soften the meat, then toro-ing the bull until it was exhausted. Finally after about fifteen minutes of this dance, the Torero brought out his long sword and drove it in the heart through the shoulderblades. However, with the first five (I guess this is common), the bull was not finished off by this ´´final blow,´´ and was stabbed with a palm-length dagger quicky at the base of the skull, behind the horns, after the bull was so tired it fell to the ground. The blood quite literally bubbled out of the flesh, glinting almost metallic red on the black skin of the creature. However, during the last fight, the whole rhythm changed. The Torero fell and was trampled, which is extremely dangerous. He got up, toroed, posing dramatically with the bull pawing and snorting, later to fall again, this time on the bull. The dance between the two was intoxicating. In the middle of so much violence and what has been called barbary, there was so much honor and beauty, like you could feel centuries of history thickening the air. The whole stadium waved white handkerchiefs in respect for the bull, and the Torero drew the final blow. The bull took a few steps back, side to side, and fell, the only one that died from the final blow, a great honor to both parties. Even in memory the event brings a sort of ache as I am writing. It was so filled with every kind of emotion, of ancient and new, and blood and violence and history and perfume, of rhythm and art and dance, of symbolism and metaphor. It´s one of those things that really strikes a person, and I wouldn´t give up the experience for anything.

10 comments:

Ashlee said...

as a side note to not eating meat....

I'm curious about your views on animal research.

I toured KU's animal research facility yesterday and I kind of came out a little shaken....perhaps distantly similar to your feeling--I witnessed medical/scientific history, know first-hand how it impacts peoples lives, but I still have so much respect for the animal.

In the end I think I'm pro animal research in most areas (ie not cosmetic or superficial shit), but some ethical questions were brought to my attention. So, what do Suzy and Greg think?

Ashlee said...

(erm, not eating beef, cause I know you'll make the distinction)

Rob said...

Sorry to disagree with you Suzy... but ritualistic killing of animals is kinda BS... (I feel the same way about hunting for sport). I'm sure the bull, fighting for his life, felt the situation was neither full of culture or honor.

But then again, thats a pretty hipocratic view considering I <3 red meat.

Meh

Lewis Byrn said...

Suzy:
And I'm sure that you've attended a bullfight before, right? ;) I thought it would be, too... but... there it was. I stood corrected. It's hard to have an opinion about something before you've experienced it, no?

As far as animal research, I think there's too many questions built in that phrase, "animal research," that would be worth answering. If you'd like to define parameters for what you're asking, I'd love to elaborate on my opinions.

Ashlee said...

Oh Suzy, must we define parameters on both of our blogs? How exhausting ;) I should just copy and paste your comments back and forth- haha. So, for this blog, these are my favorite of your suggestions:

1) The right (or not) to mutate other creatures in favor of our own dominance

2) The hypocrisy (or not) of vegetarians/vegans

#3) Scientific or laboratory ethics

I'm too indecisive, so let I'll let you decide. You know me, I could listen to you all day--even about blood and gore ;) So, it no matta'. You. Pretty words. Start.

Heehee.

Kade said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Kade said...

From Kade: I saw this documentary about Mexican Lucha Libre wrestlers who wore their costumes in public, basically taking on the role of local superhero. They are social activists for things like poverty, the rights of workers and tenants, the environment, the gay community, and there was one luchador who was against bullfighting. In protest, he took a bunch of bull organs and dumped them on the steps of the legislative building in Mexico City. Check out the website of the doc: http://www.opencityworks.com/superamigos/
Go into official site, and when you get to the faces of the luchadors, go to Super Animal (he's the guy)

Ashlee said...

Didn't you write a poem about bull fighting?

Ashlee said...

Thank you suga. I'm happy it moved you :)

Halloween pictures coming soon!

Ashlee said...

Wow wow wow. We have to talk! IM: 1:00 my time? I have some crazy news.